Advertising · Complaints
TV advert complaints and the ITC Advertising Standards Code, from clearance to ruling
Anyone who wanted to complain about a TV advert between 1991 and 2003 wrote to the Independent Television Commission. This guide explains how those complaints were judged, what the ITC's advertising complaints reports recorded, which cases drew the most complaints, and where the same complaint goes today.
- 7,830complaints about adverts in 2002
- 136commercials with complaints upheld, 2002
- 2 Sep 2002revised Advertising Standards Code
- 1 Nov 2004ASA takes over TV ad complaints
01Who handled TV advert complaints,…
- 01Who handled TV advert complaints,…
- 02Pre-clearance by the BACC
- 03How a complaint moved through the ITC
- 04What viewers complained about
- 05TV advert complaints that made the…
- 06Reading the ITC advertising…
- 07Sanctions behind the Advertising…
- 08How to complain about a TV advert…
- 09Questions about TV advert complaints…
Who handled TV advert complaints, 1991 to 2003
The legal basis for TV advert complaints was section 9 of the Broadcasting Act 1990, which gave the ITC a duty to draw up a code governing standards and practice in advertising, to consult on it, and to do all it could to make sure licensees observed it. The Act also let the Commission direct a broadcaster to drop a particular advert, or to keep it out of particular slots. Section 8 added fixed rules of its own, including the ban on political advertising and on adverts linked to an industrial dispute.
The code that resulted was the ITC Advertising Standards Code, revised for the last time with effect from 2 September 2002. It covered every commercial on ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5 and the cable and satellite services the ITC licensed. The BBC carried no adverts. S4C was not an ITC licensee, but its adverts had to follow the ITC advertising code (1990 Act, s.60). For the wider family of rules, see the guide to the ITC codes.
Pre-clearance by the BACC
Most problems were meant to be caught before an advert reached the screen. The Broadcast Advertising Clearance Centre (BACC) vetted commercials against the ITC code before broadcast, on behalf of the networks. Where a claim needed technical proof it could call on outside experts, as it did with the Apple Power Mac G5 commercial in 2003.
Clearance did not make an advert safe from complaint. The ITC remained the regulator, and it could and did rule against commercials that the BACC had passed. One gap stood out in the later years: teleshopping channels were not pre-vetted. When its last annual report appeared in April 2003, the ITC licensed 39 of them, most launched within the previous two years, and it had added staff and extra monitoring to keep up.
How a complaint moved through the ITC
Complaints about adverts went straight to the regulator, not to the broadcaster. The ITC gave that as one reason why they ran at almost double the number about programmes; another was that a campaign repeats the same commercial again and again.
- 1
The complaint arrived
A viewer, a competitor or a campaign group wrote to the ITC naming the advert, the channel and the time it was seen. - 2
First assessment
Staff checked whether the complaint raised an issue of substance under the Advertising Standards Code. Those that did not were counted in the summary statistics rather than investigated in full. - 3
Evidence from the advertiser
For a factual claim, the advertiser had to produce the proof it held. Technical evidence could be sent to an independent expert. - 4
The decision
The ITC decided whether the complaints were upheld or not upheld. An upheld complaint usually meant the advert could not be shown again, or only in a changed form or at a later hour. - 5
Publication
Cases of substance were summarised in the ITC's advertising complaints reports, giving the advertiser, the number of complainants, the issue, the assessment and the outcome.
TV advert complaints that made the news
Most TV advert complaints attracted little notice. A handful, below, show the range of outcomes, from a full ban to complaints rejected outright.
| Advert | Year | Complaints | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freeserve nudist campaign | 2001 | 228 | Not upheld |
| PC World, Intel Pentium 4 | 2001 | 143 | Misleading on internet speed |
| Hewlett Packard tram ambush | 2001 | 93 viewers | Upheld: could encourage harmful copying |
| Microsoft Xbox, Life is short | 2002 | 136 | Removed from UK television |
| Pot Noodle, slag of all snacks | 2002 | More than 300 | Withdrawn |
| Hula Hoops Shoks | 2002 | 133 | Not before 7pm |
| McDonald's Steak Premiere | 2003 | 4 | Misleading, not to be shown again |
| Apple Power Mac G5 | 2003 | 8 | Misleading, upheld |
The Apple case is told in full in the Power Mac G5 case file. Only eight viewers complained, and the commercial still could not be shown again in its original form.
A term capable of causing such offence among viewers was not suitable for transmission at any time.
Reading the ITC advertising complaints reports
The ITC's advertising complaints reports were case summaries, not verbatim files. Each entry named the advertiser and product, gave the number of complainants, and set out four parts: the background, the issue raised, the ITC's assessment and its conclusion. A conclusion of "complaints upheld" was usually followed by the rule that had been breached, such as Rule 5.2.1 in the Apple file.
The Pot Noodle file shows how a ruling could move in stages. Early complaints led the ITC to restrict the campaign to slots after the 9pm watershed. Viewers kept writing, and the final report found the word itself unacceptable at any hour. The McDonald's file shows the other kind: ITC staff bought Steak Premiere sandwiches themselves and found less filling than the commercial suggested.
Sanctions behind the Advertising Standards Code
For most TV advert complaints that were upheld, the sanction was simple: the commercial could not be shown again, or not in that form, or not before a certain hour. Because the rules were conditions of the broadcaster's licence, the ITC's formal powers ran against the channel rather than the advertiser. Persistent failures could lead to a fine. AuctionWorld, a teleshopping channel, was responsible for 225 upheld complaints about late deliveries early in 2002, and when the problems came back later that year the ITC fined it £10,000.
Sponsorship breaches were handled under a separate code but by the same staff. The heaviest sanction of 2001 came in that area: a £100,000 fine on London Weekend Television, after payments by nightclubs were found to have influenced their appearance in the late night music programme Club@Vision.
How to complain about a TV advert today
The ITC's work on advertising passed to Ofcom on 29 December 2003. On 1 November 2004 Ofcom contracted the job of judging TV and radio adverts to the Advertising Standards Authority, which now applies the UK Code of Broadcast Advertising (the BCAP Code).
- 1
Note the details
Write down the channel, the date and time, and the product or brand. A screenshot or recording of the advert helps. - 2
Complain to the ASA
Use the form at asa.org.uk. The ASA deals with the content of adverts on TV, radio and video-on-demand services. - 3
Say what is wrong
Explain whether you think the advert is misleading, harmful or offensive, or shown at the wrong time for children. - 4
Sponsorship and ad minutes
Complaints about programme sponsorship, the amount of advertising or the scheduling of breaks stayed with Ofcom after 2004.
The page on how to complain today lists every route, including complaints about programmes. Terms such as BACC and BCAP are explained in the glossary.
Questions about TV advert complaints and the ITC
From 1 January 1991 the Independent Television Commission handled TV advert complaints for commercial channels. Ofcom took over on 29 December 2003, and the Advertising Standards Authority has dealt with them since 1 November 2004.
To complain about a TV advert now, viewers use the Advertising Standards Authority's online form at asa.org.uk. Give the channel, date, time and product, and say why you think the advert breaks the rules.
They were published summaries of complaints that raised an issue of substance under the Advertising Standards Code. Each entry gave the advertiser, the number of complainants, the issue, the ITC's assessment and whether the complaints were upheld.
The Pot Noodle slag of all snacks campaign, which drew more than 300 complaints. The ITC first restricted it to slots after 9pm and then ruled that the word was not suitable for broadcast in an advert at any time.
Its powers ran against the licensed broadcaster, not the advertiser. In practice it stopped or restricted commercials, and it fined channels for repeated breaches, such as the £10,000 penalty on the teleshopping channel AuctionWorld in 2002.
Yes. Clearance reduced the risk but did not bind the regulator. The Apple Power Mac G5 commercial, for example, was cleared by the BACC and later found misleading by the ITC.
Sources 14
- Broadcasting Act 1990, section 8 (as enacted), legislation.gov.uk
- Broadcasting Act 1990, section 9 (as enacted), legislation.gov.uk
- Osborne Clarke marketinglaw: ITC swansong (ITC annual report for 2002)
- Osborne Clarke marketinglaw: ITC annual report published (report for 2001)
- BBC News: Pot Noodle advert 'caused offence' (19 August 2002)
- BBC News: McDonald's food advert banned (3 March 2003)
- The Register: ITC bans 'offensive' Xbox TV ad (5 June 2002)
- The Register: Watchdog bans Apple Power Mac G5 ads (11 November 2003)
- 4rfv UK Broadcast News: ITC publishes revised Advertising Standards Code (28 August 2002)
- BBC News: Ofcom loses screen ads complaints (1 November 2004)
- Osborne Clarke marketinglaw: New TV/radio ad complaint handling system is go for 1 November 2004
- ASA: Self-regulation and co-regulation
- ASA: Make a complaint
- Communications Act 2003 (Commencement No. 2) Order 2003, legislation.gov.uk
Read next